You Can’t Afford Free Group Software
October 4th, 2007Many small and mid-size associations allow their committees, sections and SIGs to utilize open or free group software from Yahoo or Google (and others). And, what could be better? It’s free and it let’s members interact. But, as with most things in life, using this free software comes with some heavy long and short term costs.
When a committee or board is allowed to use a non-association resource for communication (other than email) the association pays. In the short-term, that free software does not always work. As a result association staff have to know how to use and problem solve on it. This is an expensive investment in staff time. Plus, in most associations, different groups use different packages. Having staff know and interact with multiple packages takes time and training – two things most association have in short supply.
But, almost more important than the short-term costs, not having member online group interactions integrated within your association’s software carries some pretty significant long-term costs. These costs are best viewed as opportunities that you lose by using these free packages. Or, on the more positive side, if you integrate these activities into your association software solution you can gain a few key benefits:
- Promotion of the association name and brand
- Leveraging this interaction as a valued member benefit
- Better monitoring and moderating content and topics
- Making the history searchable for members
Let’s take a deeper look at each one of these topics in more detail.
- Association brand promotion. By allowing members to use something like Yahoo groups to interact with other members, why do they then need to be a member of an association? Why pay the dues? If members can access other members for free, why would they want or need to pay the association dues? The association’s brand should convey that membership provides value by facilitating access to the leading members of any trade or profession. The association brand must instill that it is the best place to get the best information and access to the best resources. This is not accomplished by the outsourcing your community building efforts to free solutions.
- Control membership value. Relying on free community sites means giving away control to access to your most valuable asset: your members. A number of associations are now realizing that members that no longer pay dues are still getting the interaction through these free groups. Dropping out of the organization should mean you no longer get to participate in the benefits of the association. Too bad this is not a reality in this scenario.
- Content moderation. For many organizations it is vital that the content in these groups be moderated by knowledgeable individuals. Staff may or may not be the ones moderating these off-site groups. The more control over the content through moderation the more value the association can provide to a membership.
- Searchable history. The interaction between these members in online groups is extremely valuable both today and tomorrow. By providing this service on your own organizational Web site, your members can benefit from the great search features that can provide benefit years down the road to new members. The history of many topics can be captured and stored for future reference. This is a great starting place for many new members to get up to speed on important topics.
It is important to realize that while many of these services are “free,” there is a cost to giving up this important service to an outside resource. Over the long term, this free service could end up costing you a significant amount of staff time and/or revenue from members that no longer renew because they can get one of the most valuable services of your association for “free.”
——————————————————————————————
For more than a decade, clients have counted on Synergistic Networks to deliver technology solutions that forward their mission and objectives. If you have grown tired of jargon and chasing the latest trend and need an Internet strategy that delivers results – then we are the right firm for you. SynNet works with over 75 associations and non-profits providing Website design, e-commerce web design and e-commerce shopping carts , e-Learning software and other association software to groups all over North America.